Air Fryer PBJ

This air fryer PBJ takes the nostalgic peanut butter and jelly sandwich and gives it a golden, crispy upgrade no skillet required! It’s the perfect sweet-savory snack or quick lunch when you’re craving comfort with a little crunch. And if you’re a fan of air fryer recipes, you’re going to love how this one turns out!

Whether you’re cooking for picky toddlers, trying something new, or just want to level up your go-to sandwich, this is a fun and easy recipe to try.

If you loved this, check out my Air Fryer Bang Bang Cauliflower next!

Why You’ll Love This Air Fryer Peanut Butter and Jelly Sandwich

This air fryer peanut butter and jelly sandwich is a quick, mess-free way to upgrade a classic. The air fryer creates a perfectly crispy crust just like an air fryer grilled cheese while the inside stays warm and gooey. It’s ideal for busy mornings, after-school snacks, or a cozy late-night bite. Plus, no stovetop needed!

Kids and adults both love this nostalgic favorite with a fun twist. It’s easy to customize with different breads, nut butters, or jams. Want something even simpler? It’s similar to an air fryer uncrustable, but homemade and tastier.

Whether you’re new to air fryer recipes or looking to get creative, this one’s a keeper. Trust me it’ll become a go-to snack in your weekly rotation. Once you try it, you’ll never go back to cold sandwiches again!

Ingredients You’ll Need

• Bread: We love brioche for its sweet, buttery flavor and thick slices. Sourdough, Texas toast, or multigrain work too.
• Peanut butter: Smooth or chunky. You can also use almond, cashew, or sunflower seed butter.
• Jelly or jam: Go classic with strawberry or grape, or try raspberry, blueberry, or even fig preserves.
• Butter: Softened salted butter for spreading. Use plant-based alternatives if needed.

How to Make Air Fryer PBJ

Making a warm, crispy air fryer peanut butter and jelly sandwich is easier than you think and way more delicious than the standard cold version. With just a few pantry staples and less than 10 minutes, you can recreate this childhood favorite with a golden, toasted twist. Here’s how to do it:

1. Prepare the Bread

Start with two slices of your favorite bread. Brioche works best because it’s thick and slightly sweet, but whole wheat, sourdough, or even gluten-free options hold up well in the air fryer.

2. Add the Fillings

Spread 1.5 tablespoons of peanut butter evenly on one slice of bread. On the other slice, spread about 1 tablespoon of jelly or jam. Keep the spreads about ¼ inch from the edges to avoid overflow while cooking this step is key to avoiding a messy air fryer basket.

Variation Tip: Want to make it like a peanut butter fluff air fryer sandwich? Add a layer of marshmallow fluff for a gooey, sweet upgrade!

3. Assemble and Butter the Bread

Press the slices together to form a sandwich. Then, spread a thin layer of softened butter on the outside of both slices. This helps create that irresistible, golden crust similar to an air fryer grilled cheese. If you prefer a lighter version, use olive oil spray or a plant-based butter alternative.

4. Air Fry to Perfection

Preheat your air fryer to 350°F (if your model recommends it). Place the sandwich in the basket, butter side down. Cook for 3 minutes, then flip and cook for another 1 to 3 minutes. You’re aiming for a crispy, golden exterior and a warm, melty inside.

Quick Tip: Keep an eye on it after flipping to avoid over-toasting. All air fryer recipes can vary slightly depending on the model and settings.

5. Let It Cool and Serve

Once cooked to your desired crispness, let the sandwich cool for 5 minutes. This helps the filling set and prevents burns from the hot jelly. Slice diagonally for that classic PBJ look and serve warm.

Bonus Tip: You can also cut off the crusts before air frying to make it feel more like a homemade air fryer uncrustable!

Tips for the Perfect Air Fryer PBJ

• No need to preheat the air fryer.
• Thicker bread holds up best.
• Check after flipping in 1-minute intervals for that perfect toast.
• Slightly press the sandwich before frying to keep it sealed.

FAQs

Related Recipes You Might Love

• Deli-Style Pastrami Sandwich
• This bold, deli-style pastrami sandwich is stacked with juicy meat, tangy pickles, and melty cheese perfect for when you’re craving a hearty, savory bite at home.
• Chicken Avocado Wrap
• Fresh, flavorful, and filling, this chicken avocado wrap is a quick lunch or light dinner packed with lean protein, creamy avocado, and crunchy veggies.
• Healthy Chicken Salad Recipe
• This lighter take on chicken salad is creamy, protein-rich, and perfect for meal prep. Serve it on lettuce, in a sandwich, or with crackers!
• Cold Roast Beef Sandwich
• Layered with tender roast beef, crisp veggies, and your favorite spread, this cold sandwich makes a flavorful and easy lunch you can prep ahead.

conclusion

This air fryer peanut butter and jelly sandwich brings a crispy, golden twist to a beloved classic. Whether you’re craving a warm snack or exploring easy air fryer recipes, this quick fix is family-friendly and delicious. From a DIY air fryer uncrustable to a sweet spin on air fryer grilled cheese, this recipe is worth bookmarking. Don’t forget to pin it and share with fellow air fryer fans!

Thanks so much for stopping by! If you give this air fryer peanut butter and jelly sandwich a try, I’d love to hear what you think. Leave a star rating and comment below!

Don’t forget to pin this recipe to your favorite Air Fryer Recipes board on Pinterest so you can find it later. Let’s keep cooking fun and stress-free!

Print